Prepared by Dr. Chandra Setiawan *)
I. Introduction
It is said in the Book of Lunyu (The Analects) XVI: 8 Kongzi (Confucius) said: "The Superior Person (Junzi)* stands in awe of three things:
(1) He is in awe (respect) of the Decree of Heaven (Tian Ming).
(2) He is in awe (respect) of great men (all sages, all prophets, all Buddhas, all Deities).
(3) He is in awe (respect) of the words of the sages (all Holy books).
The inferior man (xiaoren) does not know the Decree of Heaven (Tian Ming); takes great men lightly and laughs at the words of the sages."
Related to the theme; “The seminar on Multi Faith Education for Harmony and Peace” The question is, how could Harmony and Peace be accomplished? Kongzi dreams was to accomplish the world of Peace and Harmony, Jesus Christ pray so that the Kingdom of God be on earth, Gautama Buddha hope that all sentient being be peaceful and Prophet Mohammad wishes may all being be saved (salaam).
Let us ask again how could we accomplish the dream of the Sages, the Buddhas, and the Prophets? In order to achieve this dream, allow me to introduce what KongFuTze (Khongcu/Kongzi/Confucius) suggested us to practice that is to implement the Three Awe. And to do so, we must start from education. He believes that only through education can we educate the complex human mind.
The education is considered so important in Confucian Religion, a highway open for everybody to the world. “No discrimination in education” (Lunyu, 15:39). Human beings without humanistic education turn to be beasts. Men are born equal, but education makes them different. The purpose of education according to Kongzi is to make human being develop oneself in contrast with others. Kongzi himself expressed his own experience to illustrate that it would be a waste of time to concentrate on thinking and meditation if one failed to study:
“I have spent the whole day without food and the whole night without sleep in order to think. It was useless. It would have been better for me to have spent the time in learning” (Lunyu, 15:31).
Kongzi said again, ”The object of the superior person (Junzi) is to seek and obtain the Truth and not to securing food” (Lunyu, 15:32).
Kongzi’s faith in the perfectibility of human nature through self-effort, as an answer to the dehumanizing tendencies of the historical moment in which he was inalienably circumscribed, directed his energies to the transformation of the world from within. Confucian virtue is not only a quality, but also an ability to transform oneself and a power to transform others. As the wind sways the grass, a person of virtue is believed to be able to lead the masses in the direction of the morally good. To be a person of virtue is thus no longer the privilege of a ruler or a superior minister. It has become a necessary condition for a personal transition from a crude and uncivilized being to a cultivated and civilized person, or from being of sensation to a person of virtue. Self-cultivation is thus understood as the fundamental path to the spiritual transformation of one’s character. By interaction between the macrocosm and the microcosm, the transformation of one’s own character is believed to fulfill the transformation of the cosmos and society.
II. Learning, Thinking, Self-Examination, And Practising
Among the many ways of self-cultivation, learning is considered by Kongzi to be the most important path towards perfection. Kongzi took learning as the first step to gaining moral virtues. That is why he began his lifelong endeavour by setting his mind on learning (Lunyu, 2:4). According to Kongzi, the aim of learning is to improve one’s own character and not for the sake of fame or praise from others. He pointed out, ”Scholars of ancient times learned to improve themselves, today’s scholars learn to impress others” (Lunyu, 14:24), namely the aim of scholars of old time is to improve their own learning and morality, while the aim of contemporary scholars is to show off to others. Thus, taking learning as a process of self-cultivation pursued by oneself for oneself should be the essential attitude of all students. Learning begins with oneself but should not end with one’s own satisfaction. Students are required to extend and apply their knowledge and virtue to others and to the world, and by this extension to help bring about peace and harmony in society.
Zilu (Kongzi’s disciple) asked about the superior person (Junzi). Kongzi said,”Junzi is one who cultivates himself and thereby achieves reverence”. Zilu said, “Is that all?”, Kongzi said,”He cultivates himself and thereby brings peace and security to the common people”. “Zilu said,”Is that all?”, Kongzi said,”He cultivated himself and thereby brings peace and security to all people”. To cultivate oneself so as to give all people security and peace, even Yao and Shun found it difficult to do.” (Lunyu, 14:42)
Thus, according to Khonghucu (Confucian religion), the aim of learning is to gain moral perfection as well as to bring peace and harmony to the world. Self-cultivation is the means by which peace and harmony can be attained in the world.
Kongzi attached great importance to the virtues of humaneness/benevolence (ren), righteousness (yi), wisdom (zhi), propriety (li), and courage (yong), mutual trust (xin), but believed that all these virtues should be firmly based on integrated with learning and study. I would like to quote another chapter from LunYu 17:8 Confucius said:
• To love humanness (ren) without loving learning is liable to foolishness.
• To love intelligence (zhi) without loving learning is liable to deviation from the right path.
• To love faithfulness /sincerity (xin) without loving learning is liable to harmful behavior.
• To love forthrightness/honesty (zhi) without loving learning is liable to intolerance.
• To love courage (yong) without loving learning is liable to insubordination.
• To love unbending strength (gang) without loving learning is liable to lead to indisciplin.
To learn extensively while having a firm and sincere will, and to inquire with earnestness while reflecting what one has learnt, are believed to be essential for a good character. Through learning, humans can develop moral strength and move forwards to moral virtue. There for, in the hands of the Confucian masters, learning becomes a primary tool to facilitate the process of transformation from what is realized to what should be realized, from the animal-like to the fully human, from the uncivilized to the civilized, and from the uncultivated to the cultivated. In this way Confucian religion demonstrates that ‘to learn’ is synonymous with ‘to live’, ‘to improve’ or even ‘to be eternal’.
Kongzi taught his students through six subjects, which are also known as six arts. These were rites, music, archery, charioteering, writing, and mathematics. These subjects are all related to the cultivation of the virtues, such as propriety, wisdom, courage, and so on. Among them, learning rites (li) and music is most relevant to moral cultivation. According to Kongzi that it was not enough only to be wise, courageous, and versatile, but that in order to be a “complete person”, one must be refined by ritual (li) or propriety and music. (Lunyu, 14:12). For example, when asked about how to become a person of virtue, Kongzi answered,” do not look, listen, speak and move unless it is in accordance with the rites” (Lunyu, 12:1).
Kongzi also put an emphasis on the importance of thinking in self-cultivation. He believe that to study and learn is no doubt a prerequisite of self-improvement, but it should be reinforced by careful thinking. He said,” Learning without thinking is labor cost; thinking without learning is perilous.” (Lunyu 2:15). In other words, learning without thinking will make one at a loss as to what to do and thinking without learning will turn into an empty dream.
III. Li (ritual/propriety) and ren (humaneness)
Confucian virtues which have served as the basis of East Asian society for at least 2.000 years, are directed toward the creation of a harmonious society and a virtuous, benevolent state. It believed that these ideals can be achieved through the practice of li (ritual/propriety) and ren (humaneness).
At the heart of Confucian ethics is the li, the guiding principle of all things great and small. (Lunyu, 1:12), which is held to be the behavior of the sages of antiquity as recorded in the classic text. Li has a range of meanings: rituals, propriety, etiquette, and ceremony; it denotes ideal behavior, and moral and righteous action, and is the means by which one works to “cut, carve, file and polish”, in order to become a superior person and cultivate ethical behavior. Kongzi said,”If you do not learn the li, rules propriety, your character cannot be established” (Lunyu, 16:13).
Ren is the central doctrine in Confucian ethics. Ren is defined as goodness, humaneness, love, benevolence, human-heartedness, and humanity. The word is rendered with two component parts that denote “person” and “two”, indicating the relationship between two people.
Other forms of cultivation also contribute to ethical development. Refinement is the arts, or wen, follows the example of the sages who created poetry, music, and ritual. According to Kongzi, those who study literature extensively and who are restrained by the li, are truly superior, and will not violate the “Confucian Way”. Thus, Confucians strive to master the fine arts---such refinement is the mark not only of aesthetic taste, but also of moral training.
The li provides a template for appropriate action which, once internalized, is expressed in human inter-action. The actions of the self-cultivated person are ren, the ethical term referred to most frequently by Kongzi in the Lunyu (the Analects). Together li and ren form the basis of ethical behavior which is balanced between self-cultivation and learning and the effortless extension of learning into human interaction.
Action in accordance with ren is manifest in attitude and external expression in two other virtues---reciprocity (shu) and sincerity (zhong). Reciprocity forms the basis of the Confucian golden rule----“What you do not want done to you, do not do to others” (Lunyu 15:24). Rather than assuming that others will like what one likes, one must consider actions from the other person’s point of view. The ethic of zhong provides a basis for the action of reciprocity---sincerity is a feeling, an internal orientation, that manifest itself in proper action.
An ordered, harmonious society is dependent on self-education and on each person playing his or her part appropriately with good intent. Confucians hold that actions are transformative---to become an ethical person, one must be self-cultivated through study and practice of appropriate behavior.
In Confucian Religion perspective demands that all people be treated with humanity (ren).
All interaction must be based in ren, but specific actions are delineated within a clearly defined hierarchy (hierarchy is considered to be natural and essential to the creation of harmony). Key roles and corresponding virtues are outlined in the “Five Relationships”, namely, those between parent and child, elder brother and younger brother, husband and wife, friend and friend, and ruler and subject. Each relationship has its specific roles and responsibilities: a parent owes a child education, care, and moral formation; a child owes a parent obedience, respect, and care in old age and after death. The parent/child relationship establishes the basic pattern for other relationships---thus, the virtue of filiality (xiao) is the basis for social structure. A husband and wife are to care for each other. The elder brother has responsibility for younger siblings who owe him deference (birth order is very clearly delineated in East Asian kinship terms). The relationship between ruler and subject parallels that of parent and child, for the ruler is to provide care and guidance, and the subject is to be obedient as well as loyal. Friends are to be loyal---this is the only relationship that has the potential of being between people of equal rank, but even here, a hierarchy of age is often reflected.
Although obedience and defense are demanded from subordinates within this structure of relationships, a good son, worthy wife, and loyal minister have a duty to remonstrate unethical behavior. All five relationships (as well as others, such as those between teacher and student, and employer and employee) have serious mutual responsibilities, and both familial and non-familial bonds are presumed to last a lifetime.
An ordered, harmonious society is dependent on self-education and on each person playing his or her part appropriately with good intent. Confucians hold that actions are transformative ---to become an ethical person, one must be self-cultivated through study and practice of appropriate behavior. Ethical action includes the “rectification of names,” which means knowing one’s roles in the web of relationships that create community, and behaving accordingly so as to insure social harmony.
IV. Further about the Filial Piety(Xiao) and Ren
One of Kongzi virtue is filial piety (xiao). Children have the filial duty to provide their parents with grandchildren. The true religious motivation is that the long course of parenting is how one learns love in its fullness, and this is what good parents want for their children. The family as the basic unit of society, and emphasize the necessity for tolerance and harmony in a religiously and ethnically diverse society.
Becoming a good person, means learning how to love, which is the way of humanity and the dao of Tian: the paradigmatic curriculum for learning how to love is being a parent. Little children are turned on to love by receiving love and slowly learning those things necessary for adult responsible life. There are many surrogate contexts of long–term caring that express the same learning of love. Parental love is not only a domestic virtue but is at the heart of politics. The greatest power the leader has is his capacity to inspire others to imitate his virtue, and the central virtue in which ren is most conspicuous is parental love, extended to love of one’s family and beyond. Of course, there are many human relations besides that of a parent loving a child, including relations between wife and husband, among siblings, cousins, friends, villagers, officials, distant citizens. These all have complicated proper forms, and the proper way to love your friend is not likely to be the way you properly love your children. Nevertheless, the model of parental love is like a flywheel that keeps all these other relations in balance. You should love your siblings as children beloved of your parents. You should treat your neighbors with the respect that honors their own parents’ love of them. To be fully human is to have realized the fullness of parental love, reciprocating it in filial piety toward your parents, and living out its implications in all your human relationships.
Confucian moral cultivation is a matter of working from one’s inner self and extending to relationships with others. The first item is ‘manifesting the clear character of man’. This clear character of man consists of the original moral qualities derived from Tian. For it is stated in Zhongyong (The Doctrine of the Mean): “Human Nature is what Tian imparts of man”. Later Mengzi (Mencius) specifically asserted that human nature is originally good and every man has the moral potential to become a sage. Human nature is really what Tian gives to man, it goes without saying that this nature must be intrinsically good. After one’s clear character has been successfully manifested it is only natural that he would ‘love the people (or transform the people)’. As love is fully extended, there is the complete fulfillment of morality, which means ‘abiding in the highest good’, the third item. Therefore there is this gradual extension of moral values from the self to others. To morally transform oneself is eventually to transform others.
For Kongzi to practice ren one must, first of all, be honest with one’s inborn moral qualities by developing them as fully as possible. Secondly, one must be able to extend them to others through love and considerateness. Mengzi (Mencius) explained ren: “All men have the mind which cannot bear to see the suffering of others”. This mind is what he called the feeling of compassion. Some people are able to develop and manifest this feeling whereas others are unable to do so. Here lies the difference between a superior person (Junzi) and morally inferior person (xiaoren).
To Mengzi (Mencius), a man without displaying his feeling of compassion is not a man in the true sense of the word, because he fails to develop what is characteristically human. This is the most striking difference between the Confucian view of morality and our modern belief that the formation of moral values results from socialization. A good man is able to find joy in morality.
Kongzi said,”A resolute scholar and a man of humanity will never seek to live at the expense of injuring humanity. He would rather sacrifice his life in order to realize humanity” (Lunyu, 15:9)
To realize humanity (ren) as the ultimate value of human existence eventually became the spiritual self-definition of a Confucian. Even at the time of Kongzi, this was widely accepted among his students. Tseng Tzu, a Confucian disciple who can very well be characterized as the knight of humanity, made the following pronouncement: “A Junzi must be strong and resolute, for his burden is heavy and the road is long. He has taken humanity (ren) to be his own burden—is that not heavy? Only with death does the road come to an end. Is that not long?” (Lunyu 8:7).
The focus on the centrality and the fruitfulness of the idea of humanity (ren) in the Lunyu was an epoch-making event in the symbolic universe of ancient Chinese thought and clearly indicates that the “breakthrough” is “transcendental” in the sense that humanity, for the first time in Chinese history, was seen as an ultimate value going beyond life and death.
V. The Status of Current World
The status of our current world we should all agree is due to human MIND which are full of egoistic view which in it encompass the greed, hatred and ignorant. In the book of Mengzi, it is said that originally our Nature is good in its essence and pure, but due to the influences that come from our surrounding, our education system contaminated the mind and therefore generating so much trouble in this world.
The challenge is how can we make this world to be the world of peaceful and harmony between the sentient beings and the environment? We must start from ourselves, from each and every one of us. We should realize that our mind was contaminated from the wrong perception of knowledge that comes from outward. The same way apply to educate the mind, in this case will be using the principle of religious teaching to influence the way our contaminated mind think!
VI. Method of Multi Faith Education
One method is as what Kongzi taught us; is to respect the decree of Heaven, to respect all the great men (sages, Buddhas, prohets) and to respect their teachings. The word Respect is the key to create the learning experience for the human kind. Without respect how can one value the teaching?
To begin, we must understand that our society can be divided into several levels which are described in the book of LunYu 16:9 Confucius said: "Those who are born knowing (wise) it are the best. Those who study to know it (become wise) are next; those who are limited and yet study are next; those who are limited and do not even study are considered to be the lowest level of people." Let’s us consider that we are in this category ‘study to know’.
Kongzi respected each individual’s personality. Kongzi asked for a personal understanding of the sayings and a personal experience of the wisdom embodied in the texts. When his disciples asked questions, he always gave different answers to each student. Kongzi was who stressed building the individual personality of students.
Mengzi said,” There are five ways in which the superior person (junzi) effects his/her teaching: - 1. There are some on whom his influence descends like seasonable rain.
- 2. There are some whose virtue he perfects, and some of whose talents he
assists the development.
- 3. There are some whose inquires he answers.
- 4. There are some who privately cultivate and correct themselves.
- 5. There five ways are the methods in which the superior person (junzi)
effects his/her teaching. (Mengzi, VII A:41).
The Confucians practiced ritual, played music and read poems not merely for enjoyment but because they found the value and the meaning of life in these pursuits. In other words, Confucians internalized the external learning so that learning itself became a process by which the temporality of the learner could be transformed into a sense of eternity, and their short lifespan could gain lasting meaning. Thus, to learn is to experience and to study is to do.
Principles for Confucian Learning by Zhu Xi, in his ‘Articles of Instruction of Bailu Dong Academy as is quoted by Xinzhong Yao**
1. The Five Teaching: between father and son there should be love; between prince and subject there should be just dealing; between husband and wife there should be distinctions; between the old and young there should be precedence; between friends there should be good faith.
2. The Order of Learning: study extensively; inquire accurately; think carefully; sift clearly; practice earnestly.
3. The Essentials of Self-Cultivation: in speaking be loyal and true; in acting be serious and careful; control anger and check desires; correct errors and move to the good.
4. The Essentials of Managing Affairs; stand square on what is right, do not scheme for what is profitable; clarify the Way, do not calculate the honours.
5. The Essentials of Getting along with Others: Do not do to others what you would not like yourself; if a man pursue a course, and his way is impeded, let him see the remedy in himself.
Zhang Huang (1527- 1608), once the headmaster of the same academy, laid down the following ‘Step in Learning’***:
1. The foundation of learning is an established will.
2. The principle of learning is to promote humaneness (ren) through gathering with friends.
3. The pathway to learning is the investigation of things and the extension of knowledge.
4. The regulator of learning is caution and fear.
5. The true ground of learning is filial piety, respect for elders, earnestness and faithfulness.
6. The certification of learning is the controlling of anger, checking of desires, and moving to the good.
7. The last measure of learning is the complete development of one’s nature until destiny is fulfilled.
8. The proof of good faith in learning is in searching out the ways of old and mining the classics.
These examples show the emphasis that Confucian place upon learning as a method for improving one’s own character and not for the sake of fame or praise from others. Thus we see that learning is a process of transformation pursued by one’s self for one’s self.
I hope we can all aim in the same direction that is to contribute in creating the world of Peace and Harmony and Please! Don’t let the inferior person accomplish their ego intention. Don’t let them use the teaching of religion to bring about their political view. Don’t let them stand in the name of religion to achieve their evil intention.
Many teachers still believe that in moral education they can actually “lead a horse to water and also make him drink”. But in this case the proverb is once more right: “You can lead a horse to water but you can’t make him drink”. Perhaps educationists nowadays know more about how to make a person intellectual than how to make him moral. After all, we seem to see more intellectual than moral people around. As a matter of fact, most of the parents and even educationists are still groping in the dark as far as moral education is concerned. There is always a temptation for the parent and teacher to moralize, trying to implant moral values directly in children. But there is a limit to the effectiveness of this method. We cannot expect them to learn the moral principles by heart and then follow them enthusiastically. They are far more sophisticated than that. Moralization should be sparingly applied if at all. Any value that deserves to be transmitted must pass the test of open inquiry. The student has the right to ask for rational arguments to justify the value. The teacher cannot just ram it down the student’s throat. In our eagerness to transform the student into a moral being, we must as far as possible guard against any unwitting encouragement of obscurantism.
We must remember that, however important the infusion of moral qualities is, another vital function of modern education is to train students to think critically and independently for themselves. It would be unwise for us to catch one bird while scaring off another. And it is the method of open and rational inquiry that could promote both moral values and critical thinking at the same time, also must encourages students to work in groups and to collaborate (rather than compete) with each other in seeking new information from a variety of sources. Sharing experiences, synthesizing the new information, and seeking more information to arrive at more definitive conclusions and solutions.
The discussion should be open-ended and free from presupposed values, at least during its entire length. It is up to the teacher to use his rational arguments and persuasive power to win over the student to the desirable values. Once the student is convinced of moral values through this method, the effect would last for a much longer period of time. Moreover he would also learn to think critically and independently on his own.
Another point to be borne in mind is that we should not focus upon the ephemeral details of Confucian moral practice like the rules of propriety. Kongzi even himself emphasized the spirit than the form of the rules of propriety. What is to be understood in teaching in the Confucian moral perspective and its intellectual foundation. We should allow this moral theme of ‘the mind that cannot bear to see the suffering of others’ to be developed and enlarged upon in our own ways. The teacher should not be concerned too much about moral items and trivial details. For instance, it is important to show the student that in practising filial piety the spirit than the form should be emphasized.
Every person owing to his particular situation has his own way of practising filial piety. How to fulfill the moral duty properly and effectively is a matter of common sense and intelligence rather than morality. How could we impose detailed ways of practice upon the student? It is always a good pedagogical principle to show certain respect to him and leave something to his imagination and individual decision.
Moral values such as ren are considered as themes to be further elaborated upon or paradigms to be aspired after in various ways rather than rules to be mechanically obeyed in a fixed manner. If moral values are considered flexible enough to be applied differently, they become the standards of moral inspiration for a moral agent without suppressing his individuality and creative thinking.
Great wisdom consists in fully perfecting intelligence, in restoring morale to the people, and in attaining the highest good. To know what is proper in order and natural in sequence is to approach the truth. Those ancients who desired to set an example of good character for everyone first established moral order in their states.
• In order to establish such order in their states, they first guided their families.
• In order to guide their families, they first developed themselves.
• In order to develop themselves, they first had to acquire a right attitude.
• In order to acquire a right attitude, they first tried to become honest with themselves.
• In order to become honest with themselves, they first had to learn as much as possible.
• Learning as much as possible involved gaining insight into the nature of things.
• By gaining insight into the nature of things, they came to know the highest good.
• By apprehending the highest good, they became honest with themselves.
• By becoming honest with themselves, they acquired the right attitude.
• By acquiring the right attitude, they developed themselves.
• By developing themselves, they guided their families.
• By guiding their families, they established moral order in their states.
• By establishing moral order in their states, they brought harmony and peace and prosperity to the whole country.
From the highest official to the ordinary people, all need to recognize that self-development is fundamental. When the fundamentals are neglected, what is developed from them cannot be sound. It is unreasonable to neglect the important and to devote oneself to the trivial. (The Great Learning/Daxue: Prime Ch.:4,5,6,7)
VII. Conclusion
While the students have reported many new insights, none of these successes will work unless the teachers do. Teachers must take the good ideas and simply put them to work. Designing problems and facilitating the material of learning. Teachers (Team teaching) have to learn how to sharpen all the students’ senses of observation, listening, feeling, smelling, tasting and touching. They themselves need to demonstrate wisdom in decision making. Teachers must be role models in inculcating values such as patience, honesty, humility, openness, perseverance, self responsibility, accountability and attentiveness. These values must be accepted as virtues in the principles of life and not weaknesses.
Character is fundamental; wealth is a consequence. When one treats fundamentals as a secondary and consequences as primary, then he incites discord and encourages fraudulence among the people. So by gathering wealth one fails to acquire (the allegiance of) the people; and by failing to gather wealth (first) one acquires (the allegiance of) the people. Therefore, when a ruler speaks improperly, he will be spoken to improperly. And when wealth is gained by unfair means, it will be lost in the same way. “Positions of trust are not eternal”. This means that worthy behavior begets trust and unworthy behavior begets distrust.
Universities need to be aware of teachers who express interest. There is a difference between interest and commitment. Those who are interest in doing something accept no excuses, only results. Universities need to change people who talk about doing things into people who doing things. Workshops to train teachers in the skills are essential.
Finally, I hope through study and especially through this inter faith study we can all be in harmony with nature and be peaceful among man. Allow me to close with a statement from the book of Zhongyong,(Prime Chapter: 4), “When joy, anger, sorrow and pleasure have not yet arisen, it is called ch'ung (equilibrium, centrality, mean). When they arise to their appropriate levels, it is called "harmony." Ch'ung is the great root of all-under-heaven. "Harmony" is the penetration of the Tao through all-under-heaven. When the mean and harmony are actualized, Heaven and Earth are in their proper positions, and the myriad things are nourished.”
--------//----------
*) This paper is presented at The 1st International Seminar On Multi Faith Education For Harmony and Peace in Jakarta, hosted by the Faculty of Tarbiya and Teachers’, State Islamic University “Syarif Hidayatullah” Jakarta, On February, 1 – 3rd, 2005.
Bibliography
Bahm, Archie J. The Heart of Confucius: Interpretations of Genuine
Living and Great Wisdom. 1992. USA: Jain Publishing Company.
De Barry, Theodore Wm, Chaffee, John W. (ed.). 1989. Neo-Confucian
Education: The Formative Stage. USA: University of California Press,
1994
De Barry, Theodore Wm, Weiming, Tu (ed.). 1998. Confucianism and
Human Rigts. New York: Columbia University Press.
Kang, Hosuck. 1997. Confucius and Confucianism: Questions and
Answers. USA: Confucian Publications Washington, D.C.
Lau, D.C. (translater). 2000. Confucius The Analect. Hong Kong:
The Chinese University Press
Lu, Martin. 1983. Confucianism Its Relevance To Modern Society.
Singapore: Federal Publications.
MATAKIN. SU SI (Kitab Yang Empat) Kitab Suci Agama Khonghucu.
2003. Solo: Badan Penerbit Majelis Tinggi Agama Khonghucu
Indonesia (MATAKIN).
More, Jennifer Oldstone. 2003. Understanding Confucianism. London,
United Kingdom: Duncan Baird Publisher.
Neville, Robert Cummings. 2000. Boston Confucianism: Portable
Tradition in The Late-Modern World. USA: State University of New
York Press.
Yao, Xinzhong. 2001. An Introduction To Confucianism. United Kingdom:
Cambrige University Press
Yuli, Liu. 2004. The Unity of Rule and Virtue: A Critique of a Supposed
Parallel Between Confucian Ethics and Virtue Ethics. Singapore:
Eastern Universities Press.